Posts

Showing posts from August, 2009

'Looking' Class

Image
Next week PLANSPONSOR and PLANADVISER will open nominations for our Retirement Plan Adviser of the Year awards. Each year we receive a number of inquiries from advisers about the awards, and many of these fall into a category I tend to think of as “exploratory”—feelers as to what we are looking for. Well, at its core, what we hope to acknowledge—and, thus, what we are looking for—hasn’t changed at all: advisers who make a difference by enhancing the nation’s retirement security, through their support of plan sponsor and plan participant information, support, and education. And, since its inception, we’ve focused on advisers who do so through quantifiable measures: increased participation, higher deferral rates, better plan and participant asset allocation, and delivering expanded service and/or better expense management. A Different World Of course, the world has undergone much change since we first launched those awards, and advisers now have an expanded array of tools at their dis

“To Do” List—Part 2

Image
Being a plan fiduciary is a tough job—and one that, it’s probably fair to say—is underappreciated, if not undercompensated. In my experience, most who find themselves in that role (see “ IMHO: Duty Call ”) do an admirable job of living up to the spirit, if not the letter, of their responsibilities. Nonetheless, there are plenty of areas in which we could do a better job. In this week’s column, we’ll touch on the rest of my “10 things you’re probably doing wrong” list: 6. Thinking your plan qualifies for 404(c) protection—and misunderstanding what that means. Any number of studies suggest that many, perhaps most, plan sponsors think their plan meets the standards of ERISA 404(c ), a provision that ostensibly shields them from being sued for participant investment decisions, so long as certain conditions are met. On the other hand, industry experts are nearly uniform in their assessment that very few, perhaps no, plans meet those standards (though the courts have been somewhat more lib

“To Do” List

Image
10 Things You’re (Probably) Doing Wrong—or Not Doing Right—as a Plan Fiduciary Being a plan fiduciary is a tough job—and one that, it’s probably fair to say—is underappreciated, if not undercompensated. In my experience, most who find themselves in that role (see “IMHO: Duty Bound”) I think do an admirable job of living up to the spirit, if not the letter, of their responsibilities. Nonetheless, there are plenty of areas in which we could do a better job, and the purpose of this column—and the one will follow it next week—is to focus on those issues that come up regularly in my discussions with plan sponsors, advisers, and industry experts. A couple of disclaimers up front: first, if you’re taking the time to read this, odds are you are probably doing a better-than-average job as a plan fiduciary. Second, you may well be able to identify things that are not on this list. This is a list compiled based on three decades of experience working with retirement plans; numerous conversation

Duty 'Calls'

Image
When it comes to qualified retirement plans, there are three kinds of people: people who are fiduciaries and know it, people who aren’t fiduciaries and know it, and people who are fiduciaries and don’t know it. Now, for the most part, those in the first category are in pretty good shape. Oh, there are a plethora of ways in which a fiduciary can fail to uphold his or her responsibilities under the Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA)—but, in my experience, if you’re at least trying to do the right thing(s), and taking the time to document that effort, you’re in good shape. Still, even those who are trying to do the right things—and who embrace that role—don’t always fully appreciate the implications. The second category mostly tends to include those folks or firms that provide services to the retirement plan fiduciaries. Most enjoy that status because they don’t technically have any authority to do anything on their own; they just help those who do know what to do. Of co

“Talent” Ed

Image
As a kid, I remember sitting in church listening to a sermon about what I have since come to know as the “parable of the talents,” found in the book of Matthew in the New Testament. Now, for those of you who slept through those sermons, the story (1) is about a man who is going out of town and gives three of his servants different amounts of money to hold for him while he is gone. The first is given five “talents” (2) , and on his master’s return, he proudly gives him back the five he was left with—and another five! The second servant, who was left with two, returns those to the returning master—and two more besides. Both of these servants are commended and given more responsibility. However, the third servant, who was only entrusted with one talent, tells his returning master that, knowing his master was the demanding type, he opted instead to bury his talent, so that he could return it safely—which he does. For his conservatism, this poor guy is called wicked and lazy, has the