‘Automatic’ Transmission: Does Auto-Enrollment Create Leakage?
Most people view automatic enrollment in a 401(k) as a good thing 1 – but apparently it has a heretofore unappreciated “dark” side. At least that was the focus of a headline in a recent Wall Street Journal article (subscription required) that asked (and answered) the provocative question: “401(k) or ATM? Automated Retirement Savings Prove Easy to Pluck Prematurely.” That is at least how the Journal chose to position its coverage of a study based on a single firm’s experience with automatic enrollment. That study , according to the Journal , serves to “answer a question that has long concerned employers that put workers into 401(k) plans and give them the option to drop out, rather than requiring them to sign up on their own: Will auto-enrolled workers treat their 401(k)s like automated-teller machines?” Now, I’ve heard a lot of questions over the years from plan sponsors about automatic enrollment – but never that one. Regardless, the Journal says that the study