Nevin's Data "Points"

So much of our lives have been disrupted by the COVID-19 pandemic—but the pace of 401(k) litigation, it seems, has, if anything, accelerated. Now, some may find the label “terror” in the title extreme. In fact, it hadn’t really occurred to me until I read the response of defendants to a suit slapped on Genentech Inc. and the plan fiduciaries of its $7.6 billion 401(k) plan in early October. In a response to that excessive fee suit, the defendants’ attorneys referred to this suit—and others like it—as “an  in terrorem  attack on fiduciaries and employers seeking sweeping monetary and injunctive relief geared toward disrupting employee benefit relationships and causing protracted, expensive litigation.”  “In terrorem,” Latin for “into/about fear,” has a legal context—a legal threat, really—one generally voiced in hope of compelling an action (or lack of action) without resorting to a lawsuit or criminal prosecution. It normally arises in regard to a provision...

So, how much should the plaintiffs’ attorneys who wrangled a $12 million settlement receive for their time, effort and trouble? Well, if you’ve been keeping up with such things, you’ll do some quick math and arrive at a figure of $4 million since, after all, these class action suits [i] —undertaken on a contingent fee basis—generally produce a pay day of somewhere between 25% and 30% of the settlement amount. [ii] In this case, that’s the settlement amount requested by the law firm of Schlichter Bogard & Denton for their work in a suit involving Oracle Corp. and its 401(k) plan (over 6,300 hours—5,631.10 hours of attorney time & 696.5 hours of non-attorney time—according to the filing ( Troudt v. Oracle Corp . , D. Colo., No. 1:16-cv-00175, motion for attorneys’ fees 5/8/20). That’s aside from the requested reimbursement of what those same attorneys characterize as “reasonable out-of-pocket expenses of $410,501.60, [iii]  and $25,000 for each of the named clas...