Nevin's Data "Points"

 A new paper rehashes (and embraces) some old beliefs, blatantly ignores the full impact of workplace savings, disregards the reality that deferrals are temporary—and kills a lot of trees in the process.   The diatribe’s author, perhaps because he’s affiliated with a law school, perhaps because the paper (provocatively titled “ The Great American Retirement Fraud ”) is so long (82 pages), managed to get what amounts to a long-winded pontification published by the Social Science Research Network [i] —a network that normally publishes research.  There’s little new here, and painfully little substance—though he does affix a label—“the Retirement Reform Project”—to the “conspiracy” he crafts between employers, investment management firms, advisors and those that support their interests. At the crux of this imagined conspiracy is none other than Rob Portman and Ben Cardin. Yes, that Portman and Cardin!   Reform ‘School’? Indeed, he claims this “...

Ours is an industry of fairly recent invention–one that is, in many respects, only just beginning to emerge from the growth pangs of adolescence. Ours is an industry constantly and dramatically evolving–and one that all too often seems relentlessly driven to push us forward to the next challenge, through the next legislative overhaul, and onto the next wave of tumult in the markets, sometimes in the same six-month period. For plan sponsors, change is not only the order of the day, it is the day. That certainly has been true for the 15 years during which PLANSPONSOR has been published. But if the pace is relentlessly forward, there are nonetheless those among us who have a vision that stands out from the crush of the day, who provide a better way for the rest of us, either through thoughts or deeds, to succeed in helping bring about a more secure future for those who depend on us. As our 15th anniversary approached, we began thinking about those individuals--individuals who have mad...