Does TikTok Really Hate the 401(k)?

A recent MarketWatch article poses the intriguing question: “Why does TikTok hate the 401(k) so much?”

Now, as social media platforms go, I’ve pretty much avoided TikTok. Oh, I’ve swung by it from time to time just to see what the “fuss” is, but generally speaking (and even in “retirement”), I’ve better ways to spend my day than scrolling through two-minute videos of—well, to my eyes, pretty insipid stuff.


On the other hand, I’ve long “dabbled” in social media platforms, and by dabbled, I mean I have established accounts, moseyed around, and ultimately “engaged” (some of you may (hopefully) even have noticed that I’ve been doing two-minute videos on LinkedIn for the past several months)—it’s just never been my “day job.” I’ve been on Twitter since 2008—LinkedIn even longer. Facebook (yes, I AM a Boomer, after all) since my kids got on it, and Instagram once Mr. Zuckerberg shackled that app to Facebook. I’ve read books on the subject of social media, attended conferences and training sessions (live and online) about how to use/leverage these tools—and still spent a lot of time over the past couple of decades waiting for the day when the actual response to a LinkedIn (or Twitter) post…mattered. I don’t mean the “likes” that Twitter shares, or the “impressions” or number of “followers” these platforms attribute to one’s account. They’re valuable metrics, of course—widely shared (and sometimes trumpeted). 

But as much as I enjoy social media—and relish the relationships that I have found and fostered there, in my experience it's still a bit of an echo chamber—one (still) frequented by people who are already “on” social media. Indeed, it seems for the very most part the people who are “there” are there to promote the use and value of social media to those not yet in that “club.” Not that you won’t find valuable content there—but plan sponsor clients? Participants?

That may be changing, of course. Published reports claim that TikTok has over 1.677 billion users globally out of which 1.1 billion are its monthly active users as of 2023. By any measure, that’s a lot of eyeballs. 

Setting aside the number (or quality) of those eyeballs, DOES TikTok really “hate” 401(k)s? Well, at least according to the article, it’s frequently cast as how the 401(k) menu limits your access to more “exotic” investments, and sometimes how hard it is to tap into those retirement savings. They even pillory the notion that you’ll eventually have to pay taxes on those withdrawals (glossing over the taxes you DIDN’T pay on the contribution and subsequent earnings)—one guy actually disparages (as one of FOUR reasons) 401(k)s as an effective retirement plan because it wasn’t INTENDED to be a retirement plan.  And yes, he has a product to sell/pitch.

That said, the “anti-401(k)” messages to be found on TikTok (and they still seem few and far between) are pretty much the same ones you find on any number of personal finance “guest contributors”—the type frequently crafted by individuals who would very much like to help you find your way to their “better” solution. Even on TikTok there ARE, of course, helpful messages as well—and a number of recordkeepers have already staked out some real estate on that platform.[i] But sadly, there appear to be no barriers or knowledge filters here, nothing to indicate that the purveyors of these solutions have, or should be accorded, any credibility on the topic(s) on which they hold forth. Rather, it seems that all you need is a short, snappy message, a rhythmic dance track in the background, and a steady camera (sometimes not even that) to garner attention.       

As noted above, I’ve been ON TikTok, but not established an actual account as I’ve been sensitive to the cautions about data sharing and privacy associated with that platform (though I’m only a tad less concerned about what American HQ-ed platforms do on that front). Overall, some parts of the TikTok “universe” may well be focused on sneering at the value of 401(k)s—and with audience numbers like those above—and a global reach, it’s easy to understand the appeal to any number of shucksters out there.    

But what I’d advise TikTok users to remember is P.T. Barnum’s observation…a man who knew something about shucksters—that there’s a sucker born every minute. 

- Nevin E. Adams, JD

 

[i] Though their followings seem to be pretty modest, and their messages pretty superficial.

 


Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Do Roth and 401(k) Pre-Tax Holders Really Spend Differently?

Image
An interesting—and somewhat counterintuitive—report came out last week, one that cast doubt on the “common wisdom” regarding Roth versus traditional pre-tax savings. The assumption underlying the research [i] was that those who had not yet paid taxes on their savings (the traditional pre-tax savings) would be hesitant to tap into those savings and trigger taxes, certainly more so that individuals that had already paid those taxes. Instead, the research suggested that the opposite occurred; that individuals who had saved on a pre-tax basis actually withdrew more/sooner—but with a twist.  This they hailed as good news. They noted that the research suggests investing in a CT (current-taxed, or Roth) plan could help ease concerns about outliving funds—because they spend at a lower rate (though they saw this as a negative for those who saved on a deferred tax (DT) basis).  They even managed to find a silver lining in the “cloud” of faster spending by the pre-tax crowd beca
Read more

Is the 401(k) Really a ‘Horrible’ Retirement Plan?

Image
  A recent “news” post about a blog post finds some curious “faults” with the 401(k). The news item carried the provocative title “ ‘Rich Dad’ Robert Kiyosaki Reveals Why the 401(k) Is a ‘Horrible’ Retirement Plan .” It originally ran on GoBankingRates.com, but was subsequently picked up in syndication on Yahoo Finance (at least). For the uninitiated, Robert Kiyosaki is one of those “I’ll help you get rich the way I did” types, providing that road map via books (notably “Rich Dad, Poor Dad”) and seminars. He offers comparisons to decisions made by his dad (poor dad) in contrast to those of the father of his best friend (rich dad).  Suffice it to say that his dad worked hard and saved the old-fashioned way—which is NOT his advice to you. That’s included previous pearls of wisdom like “ Why Saving Money is the Wrong Way to Prepare for Retirement .” Apparently rather than saving for retirement, we’re supposed to “look for an investment that will pay for your desired standard of living. Ma
Read more

Shifting the 401(k) ‘Balance’?

Image
A week or so ago, I came across an announcement that IBM was making changes to its 401(k). More specifically that, effective next year they were going to replace their matching contribution in their 401(k) with an employer contribution to a cash balance plan. [i] In the days that followed, the news was picked up in a couple of different trade publications—the implication being that this might be signs of a new shift in plan design. Heck, even Teresa Ghilarducci weighed in , championing the “evolution” to a defined benefit structure from the “flawed” 401(k). She never misses an “opportunity.” Readers here are likely familiar with the basic concepts of a cash balance design. Technically a defined benefit plan, it’s generally referred to as a “hybrid” because it also has a number of participant-friendly aspects that it shares with a defined contribution plan, notably an account balance (though it’s a “notional” one) that is shared with participants. The benefits accumulate
Read more